slowpoke wrote:Any suggestions on what's best to use? We're talking pits the size of the head of a pin. Seems like every time I try filling them, the filler just falls out when I'm sanding.

Sounds like a lack of adhesion or contamination, and filler that's too thick. So, wash the foil with a bristle brush and lots of plain water and then wipe with paper towels, blow out the water and dust in all the holes, then wipe with alcohol. Mix your filler a little thinner, like mayonnaise maybe, and consider doing one side of the foil at a time to let gravity keep the filler in the holes.
If the holes are really small, you can probably just ignore them and keep fairing as if they aren't there, then let your first two coats of primer fill them.
For Kevin's slogan thread, "filler converted to dust on the shop floor is fast".